Guidepost #12 – John McCarter

Posted on October 13, 2014

ELGL green icon

McCarter Cookingham

Welcome to week #12 of the Cookingham Connection. Today, we learn from John McCarter, Management Analyst in Sugar Land, Texas in the Office of Strategic Initiatives.  He follows up on the perspective offered by Cheryl Harrison-Lee, the City Administrator of Gardner, Kansas. Previously, Mr. McCarter successfully completed project-based internships for the City of Saginaw Department of Development, the City of Royal Oak City Manager’s Office, and the City of Novi City Manager’s Office.  He is a 2011 graduate of Central Michigan University with a major in Political Science with a concentration in Public Administration and he earned an MPA in 2014 from Oakland University.


Guidepost #12:

Work hard to gain and keep the full confidence of the council and the respect of your department heads, and your job will be easier. The confidence of the council is of utmost importance in doing a successful job.

This is solid life advice from Cookingham. I have always seen confidence and respect as a result of not only growth and positive action but also of conducting yourself and your organization in an honest and genuine fashion; trust being the glue that holds it all together. Even if you get incredible results, you won’t gain anyone’s confidence or respect if they cannot trust what you’re saying or trust that you are running your organization with integrity.

Having never sat in the Manager’s seat, my thoughts can only come from what I have observed from Managers I have worked for; all of whom I believe have exemplified this Guidepost.

A few years back when I had my first internship in a City Manager’s Office I remember being surprised at how City Council communicated with the Manager’s Office. Everything requested by one Councilmember went to every Councilmember. Everything from e-mails to reports to the all-important weekly Council packet was shared with everyone. I’ve seen this, in varying degrees and forms, in every Manager’s Office since. At the time I saw it as unnecessary. You know that most of the time the only person interested in the information is the person asking for it, so why give it to everyone?

As time progressed I began to see the dynamics of working with Council and I saw the power of this shared information. Sure, addressing questions outside of Council meetings saves time and can shorten up meetings but more than that, when the entire body is operating off of the same information they can move forward as one. No one is privy to information someone else does not have. This open and honest communication, to me, is the fundamental basis confidence and trust are built on.

Cookingham also talks about the importance of respect from department heads. I would even take this one step further and apply it to the entire staff. Different people approach relationships in different ways; everyone has their own management style but trust remains a key component. I’ve been lucky enough to work for managers who have had excellent relationships with their departments heads built on trust. Disagreements are inevitable but at the end of the day we are all playing for the same team and having faith in management to make important decisions is crucial.

Respect and confidence are built on trust, which comes from being open, honest and genuine in your everyday interactions. When I first started here in Sugar Land I was given the advice, “Dishonest people might shoot to the top quickly, but they are always found out and rarely last long.” The dynamics between managing staff and Council relations are very complex and something I’ve enjoyed observing and learning about over my career. The only solid conclusion I have drawn thus far is that the whole thing can fall apart if no one trusts each other.

Close window